Aura and The Sixth Sense
Carlos
Fuente’s Aura, depicts a romantic, yet disturbing love story that blurs
the boundary between the worlds of the living and dead. The supernatural
elements and symbolism depicted in Aura are similar to those in M. Night Shyamalan’s
The Sixth Sense.
The story of The Sixth Sense
illustrates the relationship between child psychologist, Dr. Malcolm Crowe, and
his patient, Cole Sear. Like his former client, Vincent Gray, Cole is troubled
by his extraordinary ability to see the dead. At first, Dr. Crowe is hesitant about
helping Cole; his previous sessions with Vincent had ended in a failure.
However, he eventually becomes invested in Cole and advises him to communicate
with the ghosts. Given this suggestion,
Cole learns to overcome his fear by helping the dead who are trapped in the
living world. At the same time, Cole aids Dr. Crowe in discovering that he also
dead, a realization that leaves the most viewers in shock.
Though the endings of both the
novel and the movie are startling, there are numerous details hinting at the
true identities of both Felipe and Dr. Crowe. In Aura, when Felipe views
the advertisement in the newspaper, he instinctively knows that it is addressed
directly at him. The nature of Felipe’s job, completing and writing General
Llorente’s memoirs, also serves as a valuable clue because memoirs usually
contain the writer’s memories. Similarly, in The Sixth Sense, though Dr.
Crowe appears to communicate with living people, aside from Cole, there is no
actual interaction. His wife’s refusal to converse with him at the restaurant,
also demonstrates this point. Although these subtle hints are dispersed
throughout the book and movie, it is difficult to deduce the truths about both
characters without reaching the stories’ conclusions.
Furthermore,
both stories contain moments that illustrate synchronicity between two
characters. Fuentes reveals a scene where Felipe witnesses the doubling of
Senora Consuelo with Aura when he writes, “Senora becomes motionless, and at
the same moment Aura puts her knife on her plate and also becomes motionless…”(69).
In the same way, the movie connects Cole and Vincent, who share the unique ability
to see ghosts, by depicting both characters with white portions in their hair. The
use of mirroring characters provides insight into the characters’ future; Cole may
have followed in Vincent’s footsteps without Dr. Crowe’s help, and it is exposed
that Aura is Senora Consuelo in the end.
Additionally, color plays a significant
role in emphasizing important features of both The Sixth Sense and Aura.
The darkness engulfing Felipe as he enters Senora Consuelo’s house creates a
sense of distortion and confusion. The audience is left questioning whether
Felipe is following the ruffling sound of Aura’s taffeta or Senora Consuelo’s. Aura’s
black Christ also adds to the eeriness of her character. The use of red to highlight
significant scenes is also prominent in The Sixth Sense; Shyamalan
deliberately uses red when ghosts are present. For example, Cole’s tent when a
ghost appears is red, and whenever Dr. Crowe is around, his wife is shown
sleeping covered in a red shawl.
Clearly,
Aura and The Sixth Sense share many similar features through the symbolism,
characterization, and story line The conclusions in both stories leave the
audience stumped, and thus are works that encourage us to reread or re-watch over and over again.
The ending of the Sixth Sense is pretty shocking, similar to Aura. Even though I have never read the story before, I can see how you would find these two very similar. These two pieces of work reminds me of short stories written by Edgar Allen Poe. He would create this sense of mystery and intrigue right from the beginning and we could never really guess the ending.
ReplyDeleteI would not have thought about making this comparison between these two works, but I really liked the connection that you made here. There is definitely a magical realism quality to "The Sixth Sense," as the plot events are not especially outlandish or visually fantastical, but are actually seemingly normal for the most part, as evidenced by Dr. Crowe's delayed realization that he is actually dead. However, the supernatural elements of both stories are still very much evident. Also, I really liked the similarities you pointed out between the two, including the subtle hints throughout each text, as well as the use of mirroring two characters with another.
ReplyDeleteIt is amazing that you came up with such a great text/movie, such as The Sixth Sense, to compare with the story Aura. Aura was such a hard read. It psychologically messed with your mind and made you think of so many different possibilities. It was hard to pin point one exact conclusion from the story. Although there was much difficulty, the point that you made apparent of possibly communicating with the dead is one that applies to both stories perfectly. Another point that directly applies to the idea of magical realism is the characters that are made to be seen as real, yet they are really ghosts. Dr. Crowe is depicted as a living human, yet he is really just a ghost. Aura is also presented as a human, yet she is some supernatural force. This trickery is the main point of magical realism: you put the supernatural in with everyday life. Furthermore, although it is baffling to understand, magic realism will stump you as seen in both of these texts.
ReplyDeleteI think this is a really great comparison. In both Aura and the Sixth Sense, the endings are shocking. The reader/watcher is lead to believe the main characters, Felipe and Dr. Crowe are normal humans that are dealing with weird and interesting events, such as ghosts and people sharing the same body. At the end, however, it is revealed that there is something weird with the main characters as well, Felipe being the dead General Llorente and Dr. Crowe being a ghost himself.
ReplyDeleteThis was very good. I also never thought of the Sixth Sense, nor would have compared it with Aura until now. Both the movie and the book share so many similarities, and I really like the idea of how color plays a role in both works. It's very interesting how something so small such as the color of the taffeta or eyes and the color red can have such an impact to the magical realism represented in the plot. The colors are very normal descriptions of the characters, yet they symbolize a magical element of a past image (Aura as a younger Consuelo) and ghosts. I agree with you about how the use of foreshadowing is interwoven through synchronicity and eery descriptions in the both the book and the movie. In the end, we are left with a startling realization that forces us to question reality.
ReplyDeleteThis is a very great comparison. When i watched the movie I never really payed attention to the details that you pointed out in you blog, like the fact that there was red when a ghost was presents. There were a lot of details that foreshadowed the upcoming evens but the reader or the view would most likely skip past them if they did not pay enough attention.
ReplyDeleteThe twist at the end of The Sixth Sense was a surprise. While watching that movie, I never paid attention to the foreshadowing clues. However, in Aura, I did pay attention to foreshadowing clues. I did not know exactly what it was that would happened, but I knew something was up. As more clues piled on, I did have some clue.
ReplyDeleteYou have made an excellent comparison between the film and the book.
I feel that both the movie and the book leave the reader/viewer questioning what exactly is real and what is not. Both present moments that distort reality and lead back to did it actually happen?
I really loved your comparison of Aura and The Sixth Sense. Each one holds some very similar things to one another; for example, the reality being so distorted. The movie's ending really made me feel as if the little hints that was distributed across the movie should have given me a clue that something wasn't right. I did noticed in Aura though. The distortion of reality makes the readers and viewers feel like they need to question what is real and what seems to be a part of their imagination.
ReplyDeleteI could imagine that if Aura was made into a movie, it will probably make me feel the same way as The Sixth Sense: surprised and confused as to what transpired and if it was even real in the first place.