In the third episode of
the Mad Men television series, “The
Marriage of Figero,” the viewer is given a clear portrayal of the lifestyle for
many Americans in the 1960’s. The setting of the suburban household, workplace,
and city atmosphere reveals the private lives and scandals of its many
characters. When watching this episode, I was able to make strong connections
to the 1947 play “A Street Car Named Desire” by Tennessee Williams.
Although many of you may not have
read or seen this play, it focuses around the central character Blanche DuBois
who moves to the apartment of her sister, Stella, and her husband, Stanley,
after losing the family home. As the
play continues to develop, more of Blanche’s past is revealed as she talks to
one of Stanley’s friends, Mitch. The audience learns that years ago her husband
committed suicide after Blanche discovered and reprimanded him for being homosexual.
Although they bond over the loss of a loved one and begin to develop a relationship,
Stanley divulges to Mitch about the numerous sexual liaisons and affairs that
Blanche had in the past. When Blanche drunkenly admits that the stories are
true, Mitch tells her that he cannot marry her. After this point in the story
Blanche goes mentally insane, and the play ends as a doctor comes to take
Blanche to an insane asylum.
Although
the plot may not directly lead one to connect this play to Mad Men, it has many parallels and underlying themes that are
similar. For example, Blanche and Don Draper both have a poorly disguised
drinking problem. Even though smoking and drinking is normal during these time
periods, in both cases, their excessive drinking can be seen as an escape from
reality. As both characters withdraw from their unsympathetic reality, their
drunken state leads to destructive behavior. Don uses alcohol as a diversion
from his nagging wife, which can be seen when he is drunk and doesn’t come back
to his daughter’s birthday party after picking up the cake. Blanche’s retreat
through alcohol allows her to shield herself from reality and the
horrors of her past, which she tries to avoid by moving to her sister’s
apartment. Unlike Don however, Blanche tries to keep her drinking a secret.
Inevitably when the truth comes out about her past, Blanche loses the affection
of Mitch and insanity emerges as she retreats fully into herself.
Another
connection that can be made between these two works are the character’s secret
personal lives and the resulting false images of perfection that are created. During
the 1960’s and the post war era, the idea of perfection was heavily embedded in
society. This concept is conveyed in Mad
Men as the women are expected to be the “perfect” housewife or the “perfect”
mother. People strived to achieve this flawless image through material items
and outward appearances such as their houses, cars, jobs, clothing, etc. This
can be seen as Helen is criticized for the car she drives and the fact that she
is a single mother. In both of these works, multiple characters create façades to
hide secrets from their personal lives and uphold society’s expectations of
perfection. In “A Street Car Named Desire,” Stanley is portrayed as a loyal
friend and a good husband to Stella. Unbeknownst to the other characters in the
play, Stanley is an abusive husband who also rapes Blanche. Additionally, Blanche also pretends to be a
proper and dignified woman who’s false etiquette is an attempt to make her seem
more attractive to men and boost her self-esteem. These misleading impressions can also be seen
in Mad Men during Don’s daughter’s birthday party. As Don makes his way through
the house with a video camera, everything seems idyllic as children are
playing, men are smoking, and people are enjoying each other’s company and
conversations. However, once the audience is able to see outside the camera’s
view we are able to acknowledge that the scene is not so perfect as Helen calls
another man out for implying an affair, women are gossiping in the kitchen, and the men are distant from their families. In both of these texts, it is evident that true perfection is never really
achieved but is merely a façade.
Both
of these texts made me realize that today our society is not necessarily all
that different. People still strive for the appearance of perfection in order
to be accepted by others. We try to have the nicest clothes, the most expensive
car, or the biggest house. People even alter their physical appearance to
become more attractive. Although it may not be as obvious today, our society
still has a huge focus on the idea of perfection, whether it is true or not.
I really like your comparison of the episode of Mad Men with "A Street Car Named Desire." At first when I read your summary of the play, I didn't see the connection, but you managed to convince me that there is more than meets the eye. I like how you brought up the idea of a false image of perfection because I believe that it is still prominent in today's society as it was in the 1960's.
ReplyDeleteI think people are constantly trying to outdo each other, buying the nicest car, having a perfect household, sending their kids to the best schools; it's all part of an image of who is the most successful or has the best lifestyle. In the end, everyone wants to have the perfect family that others will envy. On the outside this is a picture perfect image, but no one really knows what it takes to create this image.
There are people that will do anything to achieve that perfection, that image. If having the most expensive or luxurious goods to show to others is someone's idea of perfection, they can easily drive themselves into a pile of debt. This is where the false image comes in. Although having the highest quality goods may allow others to perceive someone to be "living the life," underneath all that, they are suffering from an amount of debt that only confirms that things aren't all as they seem.
I think your comparison of the Mad Men episode with "A Street Car Named Desire" was really interesting! I agree with both you and Jennifer in that people go to great lengths to create a false image, just so that they can impress others. It's interesting to me that even though we value being unique in today's day and age, there's ultimately a desire to blend in and to be "perfect" infront of others. I particularly liked the video camera scene from the Mad Men episode, and to some extent, I think that scene is representative of our modern day values as well. With the rise in use of social media, it's easy for us to create an image of ourselves that we want others to believe via pictures, videos, Facebook statuses, tweets, etc. Thus, as you mentioned in the last sentence of your post, even though it's 2013, our continued strive to appear perfect makes us very similar to the families seen in the episode and the play.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed this comparison - although I have not yet read "A Street Car Named Desire", the theme of idealized perfection as a facade strongly resonated with me as we watched the episode of Mad Men, and your descriptions/summaries of the play's plot allowed me to see it in that work as well. I think that the most interesting point you make is the present-day continuation of this constant strive for a certain ideal image. As you mentioned, perfect appearances are still very much important today. I especially like Irene's comment on the rise of social media and its role in the creation of this false image - so much effort and emphasis is put on how your online profile appears to not just others, but virtually everyone else in cyberspace. This idea of creating an online, outward persona for others to view without any actual in-person contact is the sole basis of social media, and is definitely worth examining further in relation to this ongoing theme.
ReplyDeleteI thought your choice of comparison is amazing. The play sounds interesting and exciting too because each scene seems like it will reveal some sort of deep dark secret about all the characters just like in Mad Men. Blanche is crazier than Don! I guess I can understand because she had been raped and she has to live with someone else’s family, but I cannot believe that she has to end up in an insane asylum after being rejected by Mitch.
ReplyDeleteI agree that no matter what time period it is, people try to put on an image of perfection, but underneath all that illusions, people keep hiding the problems they have at home and with themselves. To an extent, I believe striving for perfection is good, but people should still face the problems that they have. I think when they try to avoid them, this is when problems occur: Don and Blanche alcohol addiction and misunderstanding of Helen and Stanley.
You make an interesting point that both the Mad Men Episode and "A Street Car Named Desire" emphasizes the concept of perfection. Don Draper and Blanche are really quite similar in that which they both pretend to be something that they are not and in some point are admired by others because of it. I agree with you that even today society has a tendency to appear perfect or at least try to be the most successful they can be. In any social media, we can see the people try to appear more 'perfect' even sometimes lying about their appearance or themselves to achieve that. There really isn't any major difference from the society in the 1960s to that of today of 2013. I have seen "A Street Car Named Desire" for a class before and it's a great comparison to the Mad Men Episode. One can almost say that with trying to achieve this perfection, it could possibly lead to insanity.
ReplyDeleteI really liked your connection using alcohol and facades. Although I didn't see the connection at first, based on the story line of "The Street Car Named Desire", I was able to see it through the character of Blanche and Don.
ReplyDeleteThey do run from reality but with different reasons like Don is not being in dominance in the house and Blanche is running because of her past that haunts her. However, either way they still use alcohol and put up a facades to hide what they truly feel. Great connection.
In both stories, Blanche and Don Draper seem to try to hide their true identities. If I remember correctly, Blanche was an unsuccessful schoolteacher, as well as a drunk, who was ridiculed and forced to leave her home town to live with her sister. As a parallel, Don Draper appears to have two identities, as shown by the man who approaches him on the train and calls him a different name, which Don responds to. I thought this was another theme worth mentioning.
ReplyDeleteThe comparison that you made between the Mad Men episode and the play "A Car Named Desire" was very interesting. The points that you made about the two pieces being similar was intriguing because it made me think about the similarities (even though I have never heard of that play) between them as well as the similarities between the past as well as the present. In your closing paragraph you mentioned how you realized that the past is very similar to the present, and I agree. Take for instance the point you made about alcohol being an escape from reality, I feel that the use of any sort of substance (alcohol, drugs, smoking, etc) is a way to "escape" and it has been for a very long time and will probably continue to be in the future. In the Mad Men episode, we see how a family tries to display a "perfect family" image but in reality it isn't perfect at all. I also agree when you said that perfection doesn't exist because I think perfection in itself is flawed therfore rendering it imperfect. The idea of perfection relies on the person that is viewing it, and from person to person the idea of perfection changes; therefore, an overall consensus of something being perfect cannot be achieved. They show their idea of perfection (in Mad Men) because they want to be accepted by others and society. The need or want to be accepted is something that is in all of us, which is why we want others to look upon us favorably.
ReplyDeleteYour analysis of the episode of Mad Men and the play, "A Street Car Named Desire," was well-written. I agree with all the conclusions you have made about the prominent role of alcohol and the facade of perfection. Although I have never read the play, it is very interesting to see how Blanche tries to hide her drinking from others. This can also be interpreted to show how this particular image does not fit with that of perfection. People do not want to show their problems/ faults to others in fear of judgment and rejection. Furthermore, the scene that you mentioned with Don Draper recording the birthday party is an excellent example of how nothing is what it appears to be. The show did a good job contrasting the pristine with the reality. And like you and everyone else has mentioned, the idea of perfection still persists today. It's sad but true how we look to show a certain image of ourselves to be accepted and more attractive, whether it be through our attitudes, appearance, and/ or social media.
ReplyDeleteIn your comparison it was interesting that you pointed out that both Blanche from "A Street Car Named Desire" and Don try to escape the realities of the real world by drinking alcohol. Don can be seen drinking throughout the episode and eventually ends up missing his own daughter's birthday celebration because of alcohol. He is probably fed-up of the daily nagging of his wife and sees drinking as a solution to his problems. Similarly, Blanche tried to forget about her her past and present affairs by drinking secretly. Drinking became a much-needed friend to Blanche,which helped her forget about her imperfections in a society that thrived on the idea of prefection. Drinking led Blanche to confessing to her past and then ultimatley going insane. Considering Don's current situation, it makes me wonder if Don is heading down the same road. Got to watch the rest of the show to find out.
ReplyDeleteI really liked the comparison you made. I definitely agree with you that today's society is still striving for the "perfect image". I agree with Irene and Kimberlee on how the media presents images that are usually taken as what it is meant to be "perfect". The media shows images and reinforces the idea that "everyone want to look like this/everyone must have this/etc.", yet this is not the "perfect image". Perfection really is subjective, influenced by many factors.
ReplyDeleteIt reminds me of the quote -
"We buy things we don't need with money we don't have to impress people we don't like".
I had the same thought of comparing Mad Men with “A Street Car Named Desire” as we were watching the episode in class. The points you made in comparing the two texts are very convincing and I especially like how you concluded that both the works focus on the idea of achieving perfection.
ReplyDeleteWhen you mentioned how Blanche discovered her husband was a homosexual, it immediately reminded me of the character Jane Forrest in the television series The New Normal. Jane also discovers that her husband is a homosexual as well as obsesses over her age/youth. As a homophobe, she hates the thought of her grandmother acting as a surrogate to a gay couple because she doesn’t feel that they can appropriately portray the image of a perfect family.
The obsession with perfection is deeply rooted in our society, and it also ties in with our inherent obsession with judging others. Once we stop ourselves from judging others, we rid the need to achieve perfection in order to please those around us.